How do we forgive and make peace with our past? These were my guiding questions as I visited Vietnam at the beginning of this year, forty-five years after the end of the Vietnam War, to create a writing and art project, “Journey to Forgiveness.” I am a US Navy Vietnam-era veteran, and this journey was even more poignant. I had hoped to discover a fresh understanding of the people and the war, and as importantly the ongoing legacy of Agent Orange (dioxin) poisoning and unexploded ordinances. In Vietnamese, they say, “Making Peace is a treasure.” Dĩ hoà vi quý. I was in search of this treasure and discovered a wealth of new understanding. In my two-month journey from Ho Chi Minh City to Hanoi, I discovered kind and generous people, and a country that captivated my imagination and senses. It is tucked between an ancient past and modernity, a culture that values traditions like the Tet New Year’s that revers ancestors and vibrantly embraces the future. It is a young nation on the move. The girls and young women are lovely, and they’re often named after flowers Lan (Orchid), Mai (Apricot), Dao (Peach), and; Hong (Rose). Children are playing everywhere, and there is a welcoming smile wherever you go. Delicious foods are made in tiny stalls on old Hanoi’s crowded sidewalks and fill the air with savory fragrances. Families sit on the small plastic stools and share pots of Bun Bo Hue, Pho, steaming pots of rice, fish on the grill, and fresh spring rolls. Vietnam is the world capital of cooking, with its flavors and spices drawn from its tradition and throughout Asia. It is a feast for the senses and spirit! For many, it is a hard life of work and family, but there is this joy of family and life that is readily visible. With its sultry vistas from the Mekong Delta to the serene BaNang Mountains and coastlines that stretch the country’s length, I am wonderstruck. The emerald green rice paddies, from small villages to vast fields, is the true wealth of this land, and this harvest of rice has always been the soul of the country. Yet, beneath this beauty, there is the indisputable legacy of Agent Orange poisoning from the war that still has a profound impact on the ecosystem. Imagine Peace at War Remnants Museum in HCMC, Vietnam Vietnam is a profusion of farms, classic imperial palaces, temples and gardens, and crowded modern cities. Monasteries and temples are carved into the Marble Mountains, and during the war, tunnels were carved to treat Vietnamese soldiers. Though the war was more than fifty years ago, the trauma and memories are ever-present and despite these scars, the land’s beauty endures. Vietnam is shaped and defined be the invaders and their wars that have come and gone, but from the courage of these resilient peoples has emerged a country of grandeur and rugged beauty. In the city of Hue, there are centuries-old homes and gardens. It is surprising what has endured, even the elegant remnants of an imperial poet’s home still stands. This city and the imperial palace were heavily damaged during the war; yet, one can still see the monumental grandeur that was built by peasant laborers. Hue was a key battleground in the Tet Offensive in 1968, a country-wide military operation by the North Vietnamese army that tore away the facade that the war was only a “police action” by the Americans. Today, as I walk along the Perfume River at daybreak, the fishermen in their long-boats, cast their wide nets to the river, as they have for centuries. Despite the modern cities, gleaming new airports, and resorts it is still defined by its laborers, farmers, and hard-working people with their heavily weighed down bamboo shoulder baskets (don gahn tre) with fruits, vegetables, and just about anything. This nation was born from the sweat, strength, and profound courage of its people. In coming to Vietnam in 2020, for a writing and art residency about peace, my challenge was to set aside my assumptions and beliefs about Vietnam. In Buddhism, it is called a beginner mind. Serendipitously, the renowned Buddhist teacher and peace leader Thich Nhat Hanh returned to Hue this year, and we visited his beautiful ancient temple Hanh Tu Hieu. Thich Nhat Hanh reminds us, each moment is the present and wonderful moment. As I walk along the Perfume River and through the Imperial palace’s ruins, it’s a meditation on the present as my eyes and senses filled are filled with the beauty of this land. Vietnam is an ancient culture, dating back thousands of years and occupied since the pre-historic times, with a culture drawn from the Cham Empire, influences of Khmer, Chinese, Buddhists, and eventually the Western countries. Monks in saffron robes stroll by with black umbrellas. There is a profusion of Buddhist temples, and there are also the old French Catholic churches throughout the country. Most famously the Notre Dame Cathedral in Ho Chi Minh City was built from imported materials from France. Today, less than ten percent of Vietnamese identify as Catholics. Though fifteen percent of Vietnamese declare themselves as Buddhist; however, the mix of Buddhism, Confucianism, Taoism, and the traditional folk religions are the foundation of their culture. The Buddhist monks staunchly opposed the war and the South Vietnamese government’s corruption and repression. On June 11, 1963 a monk, Thich Quang Duc, calmly sat down in downtown Saigon and immolated himself to protest the war, an act that shocked the world. This profound sacrifice embodied the immense courage and resilience of the Vietnamese people. The United States had undermined the Vietnamese independence movement since the 1940s. During WWII, the Vietnamese under the leadership of Ho Chi Minh aided the USA and the Allied troops against the Japanese occupation. However, upon presenting their Vietnamese constitution modeled on the American one, the USA rejected it, and then became mired in an unwinnable war. The Americans reequipped and brought the French Army
My Beautiful Vietnam 2020
Vietnam in this journey from January to March 2020 has been a revelation. Some parts are tragic, like the children we met at Friendship Village in Hanoi with birth-defects related to Agent Orange. We have met other people who have been injured by landmines. Yet, today, if you will I want to focus on the immense beauty of this extraordinary country of Vietnam. For my baby boomer generation the war that the Vietnamese called the American war we still have many real and vibrant memories. Though we should never forget the horrors of the war, in 2020 it is time to put on a new pair of lenses. We have been savoring the vivacious and vibrant life of Vietnam Vietnam is about children and youth. There are very few Vietnamese who are our age. My guess is that more than 60% of Vietnam is people less than 25 years of age who have no memory nor understanding of the war American kids who have no understanding nor real interest in knowing the truth of Vietnam. In our Instagram social media era if it did not appear on Facebook today it is irrelevant. I thoroughly enjoy the tremendously vibrant and friendly people here. Though I do not speak much more than 20 words of Vietnamese it is fairly easy to communicate. A smile and a wave hello and wishing people happy New Year’s Vietnam makes people. My camera and computer are filled with thousands of photos of children playing in the parks, the exquisitely beautiful women, and the scenery from the mountains of Ba Nang to the charming city of Hue. Children at War Museum in Dan Nang. It is a great joy playing and talking with the children here.
The Many Tails Wagging the dog
I am on a peace arts trip to Vietnam in the first days of the new decade 2020 and the Trump administration has just assassinated Iranian General Soleimani. Whether the General was evil or a patriot is irrelevant, it was an act of war by the USA. In visiting the War Remnants Museum in Ho Chi Minh City it’s clear that the USA the most technologically advanced country could not defeat a guerilla army of Vietnamese nationalists. The USA can win the war with Iran, but like in Afghanistan and elsewhere it will not win the peace. Now, the USA at the behest of Israel, Saudi Arabia, and the Military Industrial Mafia Inc. led by an ignorant, lying, and morally corrupt President is prepared to throw more gasoline on the conflagration with Iran. Why squander trillion of dollars for another war? Are Congress, Senate and the American people willing to be lead to war with Iran? It is FUBAR deluxe, finagled up beyond All Rationality. It is a labyrinth of lies and the axiom for all war – money. All the bombs and the most sophisticated weaponry could not defeat the Vietnamese’s desire for independence from France and the USA. The Vietnamese nationalists under Ho Chi Minh had fought against the Japanese and helped the British and American war effort. In turn, the Vietnamese were promised independence from the 100-year colonial occupation of France. Sadly, when Ho Chi Minh presented the Vietnamese constitution, based on the US constitution, to US Secretary of State Dulles it was rejected. The French army that had been destroyed in WWII was rearmed by the Americans. The French were soundly oral steroids defeated by the Vietnamese nationalists in 1954. The Americans created a puppet government in South Vietnam that lead to the disaster we know as the Vietnam War. The USA’s war with Iran began in the wake of WWI and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and in collusion with Britain it sought to control the oil and wealth of Persia/ Iran. Stretching back further is the ideological war between Shiite versus Sunni Islam. The USA has a predisposition to getting into conflicts it doesn’t understand. The clueless irrationality of US foreign policy in the Middle East is a mystery that even the wisest sage cannot fathom. For example, we give Israel $3.5 billion dollars every year that supports the destruction of the Palestinian people and further fuels fundamentalist ideology across the Islamic world. The USA had overthrown the Iranian government of Prime Minister Mossadegh in 1953 and then supported the tyrannical rule of the Shah. The result of the Gulf Wars was the disaster of ISIS and the implosion of Syria. It is difficult to pick out which idiocy of foreign policy was and is most pernicious; however, the current war-mongering with Iran ranks at the top. The USA, Israel, Saudi Arabia, and all the dogs of war with competing and similar interests are trying to overthrow the government of Iran again. The tails that wags the rabid dog of war are many. Netanyahu’s impending corruption trial and Israel’s desire for complete hegemony in the Middle East and the desire to eradicate the Palestinian people are one wagging tail. Another one is Saudi Arabia’s thugocracy of pampered faux royalty and their murder of Khashoggi, their genocide of the Yemen people and their horrendous human rights record are reasons to wag a tale of distraction. Or, perhaps at the core is the 1,300-year religious feud between Sunni (Saudi Arabia and allies) and Shiite (Iran, Iraq, Mutawila (Lebanese), Yemeni (Houthi)) that is also fueling the fires. The impeachment trial of the mentally ill and ignorant President, and the vulture corporations the Military Industrial Mafia Inc. who are salivating at the prospect of war and profits are all reasons for the dog to wag furiously. Which tail is wagging the war dog? Which tale will we believe? In a world of madness which is the most rabid dog? The hoi polloi ditto-heads are enthralled by the whiplash irrationality and ignorance of a President unfit for office. As I walk through the War Remnants Museum in Vietnam today it is clear that real diplomacy and engaging in dialogue is a lot cheaper than war. The steps the Obama administration took to engage Iran were vital first steps, but the USA failed to capitalize on this and extend the dialogue. Then without any rationality, the Trump administration reneged on the nuclear arms treaty with Iran. It is ironic that Iran has been transparent about their nuclear abilities, but Israel one of the world’s largest nuclear powers has denied having nuclear weapons. Israel has been goading the USA to attack Iran for years. Imagine the trillions of dollars and the millions of lives that could have been spared if the USA had fulfilled its support for Vietnamese liberation in the 1940’s? Imagine, instead of the bombs and Agent Orange, the USA instead gave support for creating a robust society with schools and hospitals? The lesson from Vietnam is clear, diplomacy is far cheaper than war. As Major General S. Butler (USMC) reminded us, “The only purpose of war is to make the rich richer, and the poor poorer.” Cry havoc, for the dogs of war are wagging their tails and have slipped their leash.